This duel is brought to you by my love for Nivea lip balms.
Here’s who we’re dealing with:
On the left we have Essential Care, my HG lip balm. I’ve ranted about it enough on this blog so I’m not going to ramble on again. It’s the shit, though. Ingredients? Vitamin E, Jojoba Oil, Shea Butter and Provitamin B5.
On the right we have Pure & Natural in 'Milk & Honey'. When I saw these balms, I got excited. Real excited. Particularly when I spotted the Milk & Honey one (I believe the other was Chamomile & Calendula). I love anything milk and honey, especially body lotions and shower gels. As soon as I bought this, I ripped it open and furiously slathered it onto my lips. I’m pretty sure the chick who served me thought I was a freak/imbecile. Whatevs.The ingredients in this one include Jojoba Oil, Organic Shea Butter and Honey and Milk extracts. It’s also 100% free of preservatives and other bad shiz.
What do I think?
The first thing I noticed was that the Pure & Natural, while lovely, was nowhere near as buttery or nourishing as my beloved Essential Care. I mean, it was still soft and kinda buttery, but compared to E.C… nah. P&N was also a pretty, caramel colour (doesn't transfer a tint on the lips, though) while E.C. is just plain white-ish. Take a look at P&N:
The second thing I noticed about P&N? It had a scent (which I was hoping for). The scent is pretty similar to most of the other milk and honey prodz I’ve tried (kinda caramelesque) but a lot more subtle. There’s something else in there, too. I’ve been going crazy trying to pick out what is to no avail. Soz. E.C. just smells like straight-up moisturiser. Nothing outrageous/special, though. Just a very soft and light scent.
Lastly, P&N tastes kinda sweet. I like this. E.C. also has a taste to it but it’s not sweet. Licking E.C. off my lips is like lightly licking moisturiser off someone's face. Sexy stuff.
All up?
While I enjoy the smell (and taste) of Pure & Natural, I won't be re-purchasing. It's nice but I just don't think it's as buttery or moisturising as Essential Care. Boourns.
By the way, both balms are just under $4.
P.S. I used the powers of the Internet to research the ingredients of both balms as neither have the ingredients listed on the tube and their outer-packaging has long gone.
Has anyone tried these? Thoughts?